Rating: ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐/5
I’d promised myself that I was going to take a bit of a horror break…but I couldn’t resist diving back into Stephen Graham Jones’s Indian Lake Trilogy. After a slow-burning but ultimately thrilling origin story in My Heart is a Chainsaw, Jade/Jennifer Daniels is back for a frigid, bloody time in Proofrock. This sequel takes place four years after the events of the first book. After reading it, I’m even more in love with this series than before.
Summary:
The Lake Witch Slayings have made Proofrock, ID a magnet for slasher fans. But Jennifer Daniels, newly released from prison and hoping to find her feet back in her hometown, has left all that behind her. The slasher films, the trivia, the meaning she tried to find in it all — she can see now that it was a defense mechanism holding her back. So when prolific serial murderer Dark Mill South escapes into the nearby wilderness during a blizzard, Jennifer tries to ignore the slasher parallels. Even when the bodies of local high schoolers start turning up, she knows she can only provide practical help as this new massacre plays out. But a Final Girl can only play dumb for so long. If she starts paying attention, Jade may finally see that Dark Mill South isn’t the only unhinged killer stalking the young people of Proofrock.
The structure of Don’t Fear the Reaper is quite different from that of its prequel. Where My Heart is a Chainsaw alternates between Jade’s third-person perspective and excerpts from her slasher-themed extra credit essays, Don’t Fear the Reaper bounces between a wide variety of viewpoints. While we get to hear from Jade again, we’re also treated to the perspectives of familiar characters like Letha and former-Sheriff Hardy as well as a medley of new victims, opportunists and predators all trying to make it to the end of the slaughter. All of this action is framed by the words of a new essayist, a student at Henderson High who’s obviously studied the Lake Witch Slayings extensively.
I had a great time trying to suss out the motivations of the different players in this plot. Naturally one can’t help but zero in on Dark Mill South as the sure threat — he’s introduced right away as a creative killer with a passion for his chosen sport (murder). But beyond him there’s a whole cast of questionable characters whose potential motives muddy the waters: the new history teacher harboring an unhealthy obsession with Lake Witch Slayings; the twins who seem to be at the center of these new killings; the mysterious new essayist who knows so much about not just the murders but also about Jade’s life; the resurrected spirit of Stacey Graves, the Lake Witch herself.
Now the audiobook version of this novel is a special treat. It features a full cast of voice actors, with each of the fourteen POV characters having a unique narrator. Headliners include Indigenous actress Isabella Star LaBlanc as Jade, and Evil Dead (2013) star Jane Levy as Letha. Every performance was high-quality, and they add so much to the tense pace that Jones establishes for this novel.
The Jade in Don’t Fear the Reaper is more mature and self-aware. It’s clear that she’s experienced a lot of growth since the events of the first book, but still has plenty of demons to work out. But if the heart and cunning it takes to make it to the end of a slasher cycle could be characterized as a superpower, then Jade Daniels only gets more powerful in this second volume. I love her stubbornness and her…not fearlessness, but more like her determination to follow through in spite of fear.
I also want to call out one of my favorite scenes, the one where Jade and Letha are having a sort of bonding moment in the Terra Nova house. I love their friendship, and really look forward to whatever kind of -ship it might evolve into in the future.
I still don’t totally understand how everything shook out. There were so many motives, moving parts and cinematic moments. I’ll have to do a thorough reread in order to make sense of all the chaos and carnage. But this book is thrilling and jaw-dropping enough that I’m looking forward to going through it again — and maybe even brushing up on some classic slasher films while I’m at it.
This was a great continuation of Jade’s story, and I loved seeing her character adapt and grow over the events of this second installment. I’ve already read the third book, Angel of Indian Lake, which was released in March of this year. Keep out an eye for my review of that, which should be posted soon!